SMALL STATES - Check out our new series on multilateralism and small states →

Will It Be a Technocrat or an Advocate? The Search for a New UN Human-Rights Chief Is Underway


The process for picking a new UN high commissioner for human rights is underway, but civil society involvement has been minimal so far in ensuring that a “strong, principled human-rights chief” is chosen, the essayists write. The job includes protecting young people’s voices, above, says Michelle Bachelet, the current commissioner, whose last day is Aug. 31. UNHCHR/Twitter

LONDON — A new United Nations high commissioner for human rights needs to be found, appointed by the General Assembly and be ready to begin work on Sept. 1. Anyone who meets the criteria set out in the UN’s official job description can apply for this role — the deadline is July 27. The recruitment processes for our own jobs took much longer.

To say this appointment is taking place at a challenging time would be a gross understatement. Human-rights abuses are mounting across the world. Authoritarians, elected and otherwise, are dismantling longstanding laws, while traditional supporters of rights are in retreat, including at the UN. The world needs a strong, principled human-rights chief who will stand up for the vulnerable, stand behind those defending their rights and stand up to abusers, whoever they may be.

But will marginalized groups get a powerful advocate or a technocrat? So far, speculation on candidates has focused on UN insiders, and the appointment has, unsurprisingly, received little media attention amid multiple crises, with the exception of reporting by PassBlue, Geneva Solutions and Inside Geneva. This short shrift to such an important UN post plays into the hands of powerful countries who would prefer a candidate who won’t rock their boat and a process that excludes civil society.

The process is led by Secretary-General António Guterres and subject to the same guidance as other senior appointments. The successful candidate must be approved by the General Assembly. That means the permanent members of the Security Council cannot formally veto a candidate, but they — along with any of the other 188 member states — could torpedo the appointment by not playing ball.

In a June 22 letter to Guterres, more than 60 human-rights organizations called for an “open, transparent and merit-based process” involving “wide and meaningful consultation with independent human rights organisations and human rights defenders.” UNA-UK has set out in detail what the process could look like, including candidates having a proven record in acting with integrity in tackling harassment and corruption.

There is ample precedent for this engagement. Ban Ki-moon, Guterres’s immediate predecessor, consulted with civil society ahead of Navi Pillay’s appointment as high commissioner in 2008. Nongovernmental organizations participated in the appointments of successive humanitarian and refugee chiefs. And in 2016, Guterres himself engaged with civil society as part of a transformed selection process.

PassBlue Related Articles
You might be interested in these posts.
[display-posts taxonomy="category" tax_term="current" orderby="date" posts_per_page="3" wrapper="ul" content_class="pb-inpost-list" wrapper_class="pb-inpost-layout" exclude_current="true"]

We hope that he will not step back from this hard-won progress. Civil society involvement was already reduced in the lead-up to High Commissioner Michelle Bachelet’s appointment in 2018, limited to a solitary representative on the interview panel. (Bachelet’s last day on the job is Aug. 31.)

But time is running out. With applications closing at the end of July, there is just one month to review candidates, hold interviews and consultations and conduct vetting before the appointment must be decided on. This timeline makes it hard if not impossible to conduct a robust process. Civil society engagement is unlikely to be a priority. The tight deadline also leaves little time for outreach to candidates, raising questions as to whether there is a preferred candidate.

So far, rumored candidates hail mostly from Europe, despite potential difficulties in approving a candidate from the continent, given current geopolitical dynamics. They include the assistant secretary-general for human rights, Ilze Brands Kehris of Latvia; Croatian Ambassador Ivan Simonovic; and Volker Turk of Austria, who used to work with Guterres at the UN Refugee Agency and is now under secretary-general for policy coordination in his office.

Eastern European diplomats point out that no high commissioner has ever hailed from their region, although there is no strict policy of rotation. The Western Europe and Others regional bloc has had two: Mary Robinson of Ireland and Louise Arbour of Canada.

Latin America has had three and one acting (Guyanese Bertrand Ramcharan, who replaced Brazilian Sérgio Vieira de Mello when he was killed in the Canal Hotel bombing in Iraq in 2003); José Ayala-Lasso of Ecuador and Bachelet of Chile. Africa and Asia have had one apiece, Navi Pillay of South Africa and Zeid Ra’ad al-Hussein of Jordan. Some diplomats believe candidates from Africa and Asia are more likely to get General Assembly approval. According to PassBlue sources, a former deputy high commissioner for human rights, Kyung-wha Kang of South Korea, has been floated as a possible candidate. Africa Intelligence is suggesting that human-rights expert Adama Dieng of Senegal may be in the running.

Geographic and other forms of diversity are important. But so too are the qualities and experience of candidates. There is still time for Guterres to increase outreach and engagement, including by working with civil society to ensure the strongest possible field of candidates. We need a human-rights chief with a proven record of successful public advocacy at the highest levels of power, without fear or favor to advance human rights — and not a quiet diplomat who is unwilling to hold powerful governments to account.

PassBlue encourages readers’ comments: Let us know by clicking the green button in the lefthand margin who you think should be the next UN high commissioner for human rights.

This is an opinion essay.

We welcome your comments on this article.  What are your thoughts?

Ben Donaldson is Head of Campaigns at the United Nations Association-UK, where he coordinates the charity’s UN reform efforts. In 2013, he co-launched the 1 for 7 Billion campaign, an international initiative widely credited with revolutionizing how the UN selects its secretary-general. Twitter: @benaldson

Enyseh Teimory leads UNA-UK’s policy work. She has a master’s degree in Middle Eastern literature and culture from St. Andrews University, in Scotland.

We would love your thoughts. Please comment:

Will It Be a Technocrat or an Advocate? The Search for a New UN Human-Rights Chief Is Underway
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
George Baumgarten
George Baumgarten
1 year ago

WHEN are you going to elect somebody?

Ellen Tolmie
Ellen Tolmie
1 year ago

How about Agnès Callimard? Yes, European and recently named head of Amnesty I. But she’s qualified and unafraid of standing on principle. Someone from the NGO community is also a plus.

Javier L
Javier L
1 year ago

Whoever they choose is going to be better than Bachelet. Unfortunately, she has been a biased person and committed to the extreme left, with totalitarianism and dictatorships, from countries that are not even signatories of international agreements and pacts on the matter. Human Rights are universal, ideologies do not matter. That is what humanity needs, representatives committed to international law, not to their political-ideological positions.

1 year ago
Reply to  Javier L

Agree 100%. Difficult to be worse than Bachelet

Related Posts
Global Connections Television, The only talk show if its kind in the world.


Subscribe to PassBlue


Don't miss a story

Subscribe now to send the smartest news

on the UN directly to your inbox.

Stay informed, stay connected!

We respect your privacy and take protecting it seriously